#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: | Owner: pjp | Status: new Type: | Keywords: FST New badge idea | Has a description: 0 Priority: | Artwork status: None minor | External requirements: Has a name: | Triaged (triagers only): 0 0 | Concept approved (reviewers only): | 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 | -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Hello,
We need fedora badge design for the Fedora Security Team(FST).
-> https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Security_Team
This is to be used for recognizing the folks who contribute to the various FST activities.
Could someone from the fedora-badges camp help us with it?
Thank you.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: None | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by ralph):
There is already a security-related badge pending in #262. Can we focus on completing that one first? Feedback from security persons would be appreciated there.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: None | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by pjp):
Replying to [comment:1 ralph]:
There is already a security-related badge pending in #262. Can we focus
on completing that one first? Feedback from security persons would be appreciated there.
done -> https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/ticket/262#comment:8
Thank you.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by riecatnor):
* has_artwork: None => Concept
Comment:
Possible artwork concepts: see if they have a logo, a lock, a Fedora safe
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by pjp):
Logo is in the making -> https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/367
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Two possible variants are attached (Fedora Badges Workshop) [[Image(security1.png)]] [[Image(security2.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:5 piratecat]:
Hey, @piratecat, the artwork looks awesome! I'd consider putting 2nd badger's vest on badger #1, and adding a sort of cool reflection to the glasses + make their outline thicker. What do you think?
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:6 mleonova]: Hi! Ok, sure I'll try doing that, thanks for advice!
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:6 mleonova]: As you adviced, I've edited the vest and glasses. Did you mean something like this? Is it OK? [[Image(security.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by pjp):
Replying to [comment:8 piratecat]:
Replying to [comment:6 mleonova]: As you adviced, I've edited the vest and glasses. Did you mean something
like this?
[[br]] The design looks okay. Maybe we could use the FST logo in the image, in place of Fedora one? Please see: -> https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/367
Oh, and I took the vest from this web site and changed it a bit, is that
OK? https://thenounproject.com/
- https://thenounproject.com/legal/#!terms-of-use
They have detailed terms of use and licensing on their site. We should run it through fedora-legal before using any content from their site.
Thank you.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:9 pjp]:
The design looks okay. Maybe we could use the FST logo in the image, in
place of Fedora one?
Please see: -> https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/367
Hey, @pjp, I think it's a good idea, but would def be too tiny on the badger. You will not be able to read the small font. How about we keep the general form of it and put the Fedora logo on the 'badge' shaped as the lock from FST logo you mentioned?
They have detailed terms of use and licensing on their site. We should
run it through fedora-legal before using any content from their site.
I think here we can create our own content just as easily - look at security vests on the internet and draw a shape similar to it, which will be your own, @piratecat.
[[Image(http://armyuniverse.com/images/7457.jpg)]]
Hope this helps!
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:10 mleonova]:
Replying to [comment:9 pjp]:
The design looks okay. Maybe we could use the FST logo in the image,
in place of Fedora one?
Please see: -> https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/367
Hey, @pjp, I think it's a good idea, but would def be too tiny on the
badger. You will not be able to read the small font. How about we keep the general form of it and put the Fedora logo on the 'badge' shaped as the lock from FST logo you mentioned?
I draw a new vest based on the photo you provided, hope it looks better now. Also I wasn't sure which size of the logo would be more suitable, so I tried small, larger and the largest one. I can remove text from the third variant and just leave the fedora logo in the lock, if it's not readable enough. What do you think about these variants? [[Image(security4.png)]] [[Image(security5.png)]] [[Image(security6.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:11 piratecat]:
What do you think about these variants? [[Image(security4.png)]]
I like this one the most, great work! Let's get rid of the stroke on the logo and add some to the sunglasses, and it will be perfect.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:12 mleonova]:
I like this one the most, great work! Let's get rid of the stroke on the
logo and add some to the sunglasses, and it will be perfect.
I'm not sure what does 'stroke on the logo' means. I just took the original logo plus the white background. Should I make the blue lines thinner - or even remove them leaving only white part + inner blue part?
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:13 piratecat]:
I'm not sure what does 'stroke on the logo' means. I just took the
original logo plus the white background. Should I make the blue lines thinner - or even remove them leaving only white part + inner blue part?
Oh, I meant remove the blue outline
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by riecatnor):
Hiya! I think the that the lock symbol and the Fedora logo are getting a little confusing. The badges are usually viewed at a pretty small size. I'd consider removing the lock completely. I'd like to see a version where it is zoomed a little, basically so we don't see the stomach, and we can make the Fedora logo slightly more visible. Also, can you try the sunglasses with a stroke on them? I'd up the stroke on the pocket and the zipper as well. Thanks!
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:15 riecatnor]:
Hiya! I think the that the lock symbol and the Fedora logo are getting a
little confusing. The badges are usually viewed at a pretty small size. I'd consider removing the lock completely. I'd like to see a version where it is zoomed a little, basically so we don't see the stomach, and we can make the Fedora logo slightly more visible. Also, can you try the sunglasses with a stroke on them? I'd up the stroke on the pocket and the zipper as well. Thanks!
Thanks for the idea, I'll try both variants: without stroke on the lock (as mleonova suggested) and a zoomed version without lock, let's see which one will look better.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
So, I've made both variants and want to hear your thoughts about them. As for my opinion, the second one looks better in the small size because the logo is more visible. [[Image(security7.png)]] [[Image(security8.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: FST | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:17 piratecat]:
So, I've made both variants and want to hear your thoughts about them. As for my opinion, the second one looks better in the small size because
the logo is more visible.
[[Image(security7.png)]] [[Image(security8.png)]]
Hi @piratecat! Yeah, the one on the right does look better! The only thing left is to make outlines thicker according to badge guidelines: https://fedorahosted.org/fedora- badges/attachment/wiki/DesignResources/styleguide_6.a.png
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: minor | assigned Keywords: FST | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Concept | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 0 | 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by piratecat):
* owner: => piratecat * status: new => assigned
Comment:
Replying to [comment:18 mleonova]:
Hi @piratecat! Yeah, the one on the right does look better! The only
thing left is to make outlines thicker according to badge guidelines: https://fedorahosted.org/fedora- badges/attachment/wiki/DesignResources/styleguide_6.a.png
Done! Hope everything looks good now :) [[Image(security_beta.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: minor | assigned Keywords: FST | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Concept | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 0 | 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:19 piratecat]:
Looks great! One last thing - we can lose the outline around Fedora badge, and it would be perfect!
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Proposed | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 1 | 1 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by jflory7):
* keywords: FST => * priority: minor => major * triaged: 0 => 1 * has_artwork: Concept => Proposed * concept_review_passed: 0 => 1
Comment:
**Discussed in [https://meetbot.fedoraproject.org/fedora- meeting-1/2016-11-02/fedora_badges.2016-11-02-11.05.html 2016-10-03 meeting].**
Also, another question, does the Security Team have a FAS group?
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Proposed | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 1 | 1 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by piratecat):
Replying to [comment:20 mleonova]:
Replying to [comment:19 piratecat]:
Looks great! One last thing - we can lose the outline around Fedora
badge, and it would be perfect!
Do you mean smth like that? Cause I've tried to remove the blue one and it didn't look good. [[Image(security_beta2.png)]]
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Proposed | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 1 | 1 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:22 piratecat]:
Ok, yes! Perfect! I'll set it to approved.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Proposed | 0 External requirements: | Concept approved (reviewers only): Triaged (triagers only): 1 | 1 | Badge definition status: | Approved (badges admins only) | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by mleonova):
* has_complete_yaml: None => Approved (badges admins only)
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Approved | 0 (design team members only) | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 1 Triaged (triagers only): 1 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by jflory7):
* has_complete_yaml: Approved (badges admins only) => None * has_artwork: Proposed => Approved (design team members only)
Comment:
Whoops, think Maria meant to approve the artwork and not the badge definition. :) As far as the badge definition itself goes, we just need to know if there is a FAS group created for the Fedora Security Team. If not, we should request one in [https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure Fedora Infrastructure Pagure]. I'm not sure who the team lead is for the Security Team, but we should probably highlight their attention to this ticket.
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 0 | Has a name: Artwork status: Approved | 0 (design team members only) | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 1 Triaged (triagers only): 1 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by mleonova):
Replying to [comment:25 jflory7]:
Whoops, think Maria meant to approve the artwork and not the badge
definition. :) As far as the badge definition itself goes, we just need to know if there is a FAS group created for the Fedora Security Team. If not, we should request one in [https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure Fedora Infrastructure Pagure]. I'm not sure who the team lead is for the Security Team, but we should probably highlight their attention to this ticket.
oops, yeah =) thanks, jflory!
#373: Need a badge for the Fedora Security Team -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: pjp | Owner: Type: New badge | piratecat idea | Status: Priority: major | assigned Keywords: | Resolution: Has a description: 1 | Has a name: Artwork status: Approved | 1 (design team members only) | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 1 Triaged (triagers only): 1 | Badge definition status: | Approved (badges admins only) | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by jflory7):
* cc: nb (added) * has_complete_yaml: None => Approved (badges admins only) * has_name: 0 => 1 * has_description: 0 => 1
Comment:
It looks like nb pushed this badge earlier (he found the FAS group for automating the badge). Could you attach the YAML file for reference and close out this ticket, Nick? Thanks for your help on closing this one out!
badges@lists.stg.fedoraproject.org
-
fedora-badges