On Tue, 2014-03-04 at 19:59 -0500, Josh Boyer wrote:
Hi All,
During the default DE discussions, a number of WG members expressed interest in keeping KDE as a release blocking DE for Workstation. QA is now asking FESCo about KDE's status as well in https://fedorahosted.org/fesco/ticket/1243
So if KDE is going to be a release blocking DE for Workstation, we need to figure out how exactly it gets installed and what manner it would be tested in. In the above ticket I came up with the following:
install the Workstation live image, install KDE through software-installer (if necessary), log into KDE from GDM after install, test
However, that was entirely off the top of my head. Would the live image be large enough to contain the KDE Workstation already or would a user/QA tester need to install it through the software-installer? What tests should be done? Etc.
Thoughts?
This with my Personal Opinion hat on, not representing QA:
I'm not sure all/most people who actually want to use Fedora KDE are likely to be sold on doing it by downloading what they will see as 'GNOME', installing that, and then installing KDE on top of it. I think this will be fine for some folks, but there'll be a significant constituency which just wants a KDE image.
In fact we might be creating a bit of a problem, because I can see both "want KDE as an alternative desktop on top of the Workstation product" and "just want Fedora KDE" as two entirely legitimate and viable constituencies, which sort of means we've just created a bunch of extra work for ourselves. I'm not sure I see a clever magical solution to that, though. Engage brain cells...