On Fri, 20 Oct 2006 12:04:13 -0700, Christopher Stone wrote:
I'm talking about _enforcing_ an explanatory comment in the spec file.
Having specific enforcements for comments is a bad idea in my opinion.
If you see a package and think it needs a comment, you should just be able to go in and add the comment to the spec file yourself, no questions asked.
As long as you use good judgement, I don't see any problem with allowing people to do this. If a reviewer is being over-zealous of comment use such as "# use three spaces after Requries:" then this person's judgement can be called into question here.
How about we delete our ReviewGuidelines Wiki page and substitute the entire review process with a single guideline?
* Use good judgement.
And then we apply additional judgement when the package enters CVS.
Okay, this thread has found an end for me.